IN THE MATTER OF:
International Organization for Animal Protection, through
Sh. Naresh Kadyan, India Representative, … Petitioner
Union of India & Ors. …Respondent
I. A. _______ 2010,
(FOR DETAILED INDEX PLEASE SEE INSIDE)
[ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER:- ] ]
Particular of Documents
List of Dates
Writ Petition (Civil) with affidavits
ANNEXURE-P/1:: Order Dt. 16/11 / 1994
Affidavit of Urgency.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
1. Nature of the Matter : Civil
2. Name(s) of Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s) : Naresh Kadyan
3. Name(s) of Respondent(s) (1) Union of India.
2) The State of West Bengal
(3) The State of Kerala
(4) The State of Maharashtra
(5) The State of Sikkim
4. Number of case W.P.(C) No. ………381……… of 2010
5. Advocate(s) for Petitioner(s) :
6. Advocate(s) for Respondent(s) : …NA…………………………
7. Section dealing with the matter : Article 32 of Constitution of India
8. Date of the impugned Order/Judge : 1994
8A. Name of Hon'ble Judges
8B. In Land Acquisition Matters:-
(i) Notification/Govt. Order No. (U/s.4,6) : N.A.
Dated …………. issued by State
(ii) Exact purpose of acquisition & village involved : N.A.
8C. In Civil Matters:-
(i) Suit No., Name of Lower Court : N.A.
(ii) Date of Judgement : N.A.
8D. In Writ Petitions : N.A.
8E. In case of Motor Vehicle Accident Matter:
Vehicle No. : N.A.
8F. In Service Matters:
(i) Relevant service rule, if any : N.A.
(ii) G.O./Circular/Notification, if applicable or in question : N.A.
8G. In Labour Industrial Disputes Matters: I.D. Reference/Award No., if applicable : N.A.
9. Nature of Urgency : yes
10. In case it is a tax matter:
(a) Tax amount involved in the matter : N.A.
(b) Whether a reference/statement of the case was called for or rejected : N.A.
(c) Whether similar tax matters of same parties filed earlier (may be for earlier/other Assessment Year)? : N.A.
(d) Exemption Notification/Circular No. ………………………………………
11. Valuation of the matter : N.A.
12. Classification of the matter: Writ Petition (c)
(Please fill up the number & name of relevant category with sub category as per the list circulated)
No. of Subject Category with full name : N.A.
No. of sub- category with full name : N.A.
13. Title of the Act involved (Centre/State) :
14. (a) Sub-Classification (indicate Section/Article of the Status) :: N.A.
(b) Sub-Section involved : N.A.
(c) Title of the Rules involved (Centre/State) : N.A.
(d) Sub-Classification (indicate Rule/Sub-rule of the Statute) :N.A.
15. Point of law and question of law raised in the case :
16. Whether matter is not to be listed before any Hon'ble Judge?
Mention the name of the Hon'ble Judge : N.A.
17. Particulars of identical/similar cases, if any
a) Pending cases : N.A.
b) Decided cases with citation : N.A.
18. Whether the petition is against interlocutory/final order/decree in the case : Final judgment
19. If it is a fresh matter, please state the name of the High Court and the Coram in the Impugned Judgement/Order:
20. If the matter was already listed in this Court:
a) When was it listed? : N.A.
b) What was the Coram? : N.A.
c) What was the direction of the Court : N.A.
21. Whether a date has already been fixed either by Court or on being mentioned, for the hearing of matter? If so, please indicate the date fixed. : N.A.
22. Is there a caveator? If so, whether a notice has been issued to him? : N.A.
23. Whether date entered in the Computer? : N.A.
24. If it is a criminal matter, please state:
a) Whether accused has surrendered : N.A.
b) Nature of Offence, i.e. Convicted under Section with Act
c) Sentence awarded : N.A.
24. d) Sentence already undergone by the accused.
e) (i) FIR/RC/etc. : N.A.
Date of Registration of FIR etc. : N.A.
Name & place of the Police Station : N.A.
(ii) Name & Place of Trial Court : N.A.
Case No. in Trial Court and Date of Judgement :: N.A.
(iii) Name and Place of 1st Appellate Court : N.A.
Case No. in 1st Appellate Court & date of Judgement : N.A.
Advocate for Petitioner(s)
Date : 13. 11..2010
SYNOPSIS and LIST OF DATES
The present petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India seeks to obtain from this Hon’ble Court relief against the continued permissibility of cow-slaughter by Respondent No.2 to 4 as violative of their fundamental right the Constitution and obtain appropriate directions/orders/or a writ of mandamus including writ in the nature of mandamus requiring the respondents herein to take effective executive and/or legislative steps including, if necessary, to bring about requisite institutional amendment entitling the Respondent No.1 to enact necessary legislation and exercise consequent executive power, to bring about a total ban on the slaughter of cow and its progeny in solemn discharge of their mandatory duty and obligation under the provision of Constitution of India and in view of the solemn promises made form time to time by Respondent No.1 inside and outside the parliament.
The law thus laid down by this Hon’ble Court and followed by it in the later cases being the law of the land, the aforesaid judgement in Mohammed Hanif Qureshi’s case operates as disability on the part of the State including the respondents to enact a valid legislation prohibiting completely the slaughter of cow and its progeny even through its continued slaughter violates the fundamental right to Hindu.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has conform that the slaughter of cow is violate the fundamental right to Hindus in State of West Bangal Vs Ashutosh Lahiri .
As Annexure P1.
Hence this Petition.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
WRIT PETITION NO……381…….OF 2010
IN THE MATTER OF:
International Organization for Animal Protection, through
Naresh Kadyan, India Representative,
-38, Rose Apartment, Prashant Vihar,
Sector-14, Rohini, Delhi -Petitioner
(1) Union of India
Through the Secretary
Ministry of Home
Government of India
(2) The State of West Bengal
Through Chief Secretary
Government of West Bengal
(3) The State of Kerala
Through Chief Secretary
Government of Kerara
(4) The State of Maharashtra
Through Chief Secretary
Government of Maharashtra
(5) The State of Sikkim
Through Chief Secretary
Government of Sikkim
In the matter of :
Article 13, 14, 15(1), 25, 38(10, 47, 48, 51A, 246, 259(10, 252 and
368 of the Constitution of India.
In the matter of :
Right of the Indian Citizen for the protection of Cow i.e. the holy creature for the Indian society and most useful animal for the all human being.
In the matter of :
The Mandatory Non-optional duty of the Indian States to impose as absolute and complete ban on the slaughter of cow and its progeny.
In the matter of :
The non-application of Art.19(1) (g) of the constitution of India to the trade, business or occupation and/or the practice, usage or custom of trade relating to slaughter of cows special in the occasion of Eid-ul-Zuha popularly known as Baqar Eid.
The Hon’ble Chief Justice of India
And his Companion Justices of the
Supreme Court of India.
The humble petition of the
Petitioners above named.
MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH:
268. Public nuisance:--A person is guilty of a public nuisance who does not act or is guilty of an illegal omission which causes any common injury, danger or annoyance to the public or to the people in general who dwell or occupy property in the vicinity, or which must necessarily cause injury, obstruction, danger or annoyance to persons who may have occasion to use any public right.
A common nuisance is not excused on the ground that it causes some convenience or advantage.
269. Negligent act likely to spread infection of disease dangerous to life: --Whoever unlawfully or negligently does any act which is, and which he knows or has reason to believe to be, likely to spread the infection of any disease dangerous to life, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six month, or with fine, or with both.
270. Malignant act likely to spread infection of disease dangerous to life: -- Whoever malignantly does any act which is, and which he knows or has reason to believe to be, likely to spread the infection of any disease dangerous to life, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both.
It is highly surprising that despite of the aforesaid clear provisions of Indian Penal Code stringent action has not been taken against the wrong doers and they go scot free merely on the pretext of religion & their faith in the respective Deity.
12.That apart from the aforesaid impact on the public at large and on the environment, the result of these so called ritual animal sacrifices is that all rules made for animal welfare and rights are put at stake to carry out the ritual of sacrifice. There is no check, whatsoever, to see if pregnant animals, young animals, mothers with off-springs less than 3 months old, or sick animals are being slaughtered. No medical checkup is done to ensure that if the meat of the animal were to be consumed, it should not cause disease and illness in humans. The animals are slaughtered out in the open in most cases and in full view of the other animals. The place where the slaughter takes place has no safety or hygiene norms and the animal mostly goes down on a slushy mixture of blood and mud. Goats are further torn into pieces to be distributed among the temple authorities and the others. The weapons that are used for killing are often antiques with no check on their sharpnes, the animal in a desperate attempt to survive, cuts loose even in a fatally wounded condition and runs amok. The village youths then in a gallant show of bravery, capture the animal and bring it down to the alter again. Even before the sacrifice takes place, the animal is mercilessly beaten, chillies thrown into it’s eyes, rods shoved up it’s rectum to make it move faster. The premises where it is slaughtered is not a registered slaughter house so it is impossible to observe any rules or monitor that unnecessary suffering is not inflicted upon the animal. All whatever is done during these so called “animal sacrifices” is against the provisions of Rule 6 of The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Slaughter House) Rules 2001.Section 38(3) of the PCA Act 1960prescribes the penalty for the violation of the Rules made under the Act. For the ready reference, Rule 6 of The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Slaughter House) Rules 2001 reads as under:
(1) No animal shall be slaughtered in a slaughter house in sight of other animals
(2) No animal shall be administered any chemical, drug or hormone before slaughter except drug for its treatment from any specific disease or ailment.
(3) The slaughter halls in a slaughter house shall provide separate sections of adequate dimensions sufficient for slaughter of individual animals to ensure that the animal to be slaughtered is not within the sight of other animals.
(4) Every slaughter house as soon as possible shall provide a separate space for stunning of animals prior to slaughter, bleeding and dressing of the carcasses
(5) Knocking section in slaughter house may be so planned as to suit the animal and particularly the ritual slaughter; if any and such knocking section and dry landing area associated with it shall be so built that escape from this section can be easily carried out by an operator without allowing the animal to pass the escape barrier.
(6)A curbed-in bleeding area of adequate size as specified by the Central Government shall be provided in a slaughter house and it shall be so located that the blood could not be splashed on other animals being slaughtered or on the carcass being skinned.
(7) The blood drain and collection in a slaughter house shall be immediate and proper
(8) A floor wash point shall be provided in a slaughter house for intermittent cleaning and a hand-wash basin and knife sterilizer shall also be provided for the sticker to sterilize knife and wash his hands periodically.
(9) Dressing of carcasses in a slaughter house shall not be done on floor and adequate means and tools for dehiding or belting of the animals shall be provided in a slaughter house with means for immediate disposal of hides or skins;
(10)Hides or skins shall be immediately transported from a slaughter house either in a closed wheelbarrow or by a chute provided with self-closing door and in no case such hides or skins shall be spread on slaughter floor for inspection
(11)Floor wash point and adequate number of hand wash basins with sterlizer shall be provided in a dressing area of a slaughter house with means for immediate disposal of legs, horns, hooves and other parts of animals through spring load floor chutes or sidewall doors or closed wheelbarrows and in case wheelbarrows or trucks are used in a slaughter house, care shall be taken that no point wheelbarrow or truck has to ply under the dressing rails and a clear passage is provided for movement of the trucks.
(12) Adequate space and suitable and properly located facilities shall be provided sufficient for inspection of the viscera of the various types of animals slaughtered in a slaughter house and it shall have adequate facilities for hand washing, tool sterilisation and floor washing and contrivances for immediate separation and disposal of condemned material.
(13) Adequate arrangements shall be made in a slaughter house by its owner for identification, inspection and correlation of carcass, viscera and head.
(14) In a slaughter house, a curbed and separately drained area or an area of sufficient size, sloped 33 mm per metre to a floor drain, where the carcasses may be washed with a jet of water, shall be provided by the owner of such slaughter house.
“28. Saving as respects manner of killing prescribed by religion-Nothing contained in this Act shall render it an offence to kill any animal in a manner required by the religion of any community.”
The law thus laid down by this Hon’ble Court and followed by it in the later cases being the law of the land, the aforesaid judgement in Mohammed Hanif Qureshi’s case operates as disability on the part of the State including the respondents to enact a valid legislation prohibiting completely the slaughter of cow and its progeny even through its continued slaughter violates the fundamental right to Hindu and later on the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has conform in the State Bangal Vs Ashutosh Lahiri that the cow slaughter violates the fundamental right to Hindu, as Annexure P1.
14. That no similar petition has been filed in any other High court or before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
G R O U N D S
P R A Y E R
In the circumstances, it is most respectfully prayed that this Hon’ble Court may be pleased;
mandamus or any other directions or orders requiring the
respondents either jointly or singly to take effective ,
efficacious and appropriate legislative and executive measures for bringing about a total ban on the slaughter (Qurbani) of cow and its progeny.
FOR WHICH ACT OF KINDNESS THE PETITIONER SHALL AS IN DUTY BOUND EVER PRAY.
Drawn By Rajender Yadav, adv.
ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER
|To:||Sri Samar Ghosh, IAS (Chief Secretary, West Bengal), Her Excellency Pratibha Devi Singh Patil (The President of India, New Delhi), Shri Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee (Chief Minister, West Bengal), Dr. B. A. Agrawal (Member Secretary(Law Commission) ), Sri G. D. Gautama, IAS (Addl. Chief Secretary), Hon'ble Sardar Manmohan Singh (Prime Minister of India), Smt. Meira Kumar (Speaker Lok Sabha), The Kolkata Police Commissioner (COMMISSIONER OF POLICE), Sri Rabi Lal Maitra (MIC, Law & Parliamentary Affairs ), The Director General of Police- West Bengal via Home Secretary (DGP, West Bengal - Home Secretary), Hon'ble Chief Justice S.H.Kapadia (Chief Justice of India), Shri M. Hamid Ansari (Vice President of India), and Sri K.Y.S Manhas, WBJS|
|Subject:||Protect cows and their sacrifice be ban in India - Naresh Kadyan|
|Letter:|| Greetings, , |
As per Law of Land - West Bengal Animal Slaughter Control Act 1950, Sacrifice of Cows on Bakrid – is illegal because it is not an essential religious requirement. High Court decided this after 12 Years that it is not essential religious requirement. West Bengal Government appealed against order of HC in Supreme Court. On 16-11-94, Supreme Court also delivered its final VERDICT striking down the appeal of West Bengal Government; giving detailed references of HISTORY. Thus sacrifice of COW PROGENY is illegal as per law of land; as clarified by Supreme Court. Thereafter also 15 years have passed, wherein you have not taken adequate action. Thus the crime of killing cows on Bakrid in increasing year after year due to inaction of Police department. West Bengal and India as whole has lost great amount of its most precious cattle wealth in these 29 years. This is 30th year. Kindly do take action soon to stop the crime. People in north do not believe that such a large number of cows are openly sacrificed and Police is silent spectator. Cows from all parts of India come to Bengal for agriculture or MILK purpose, But half of them are killed here and half is exported illegally to Bangladesh.
Many Muslims and Muslim organizations are also in favor of Cow protection. Highest Islamic body – DARUL ULOOM DEOBAND, has given many fatwa – advice not to sacrifice cows. Prophet Mohammed had said “Cow’s milk and ghee is medicine and its beef is disease.” And “I would stand against a cow killer on the day of Kayamat.” Hence kindly perform you constitutional duty to implement LAW AND ORDER=SAVE COWS.
Section 9 prescribes punishment for abetment of offences or even attempts to commit any such offence under the Act. Thus all who are taking cows are attempting to commit such an offence and you should stop them. Your inaction amounts to abetment or contempt of Supreme Court ? You may take following steps –to save dignity of LAW:
1. Advertise in print and visual media and apply posters that “Sacrifice of cow is illegal as per law of land Or essence of order of S.C. or wordings of Islam
2. Do not allow any cattle market where cows are bought and sold, stop movements of cow on every road, lanes –prior to bakrid because it is attempt to commit offence.
3. Take custody of cows prior to bakrid and return them after Bakrid or Instruct OC of all PS to count COWS before and after Bakrid
You know better what else can be done to save cows for saving dignity of LAW. Kindly do the needful soon. A Line of confirmation will be highly appreciated.
Few lines of the ORDER OF SUPREME COURT DT 16-11-94 are as follows:-
1. The Act is meant for controlling the slaughter of animals including the cows and buffaloes and this is with the object of increasing the supply of milk and avoiding the wastage of animal power necessary for improvement of agriculture; But so far as healthy animals like cows are concerned there is a complete ban on slaughtering them.
2. Therefore, it is not essential for Muslims to earn religious merit by insisting on sacrificing only healthy cows on Bakri Idd. Consequently, the State will not have any jurisdiction or power to invoke section 12 for fulfilling such optional religious practice of Muslim community.
3. No person shall slaughter any animal unless he has obtained in respect thereof a certificate under sub-section (2) or sub-section (3) that the animal is fit for slaughter. As per sub-section (2) a certificate is required to be issued by the concerned authorities that the animal is over 14 years of age and is unfit for work or breeding or that the animal has become permanently incapacitated from work or breeding due to age, injury, deformity or any incurable disease.
4. As per section 5 even if there is a certificate enabling a person to get concerned animal slaughtered he cannot slaughter it in any place other than the place prescribed in that behalf. As per section 7 whoever contravenes the provision of the Act shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months or with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees or with both. Section 8 makes the offences cognizable under the Act. Section 9 prescribes punishment for abetment of offences or even attempts to commit any such offence under the Act. The aforesaid relevant provisions clearly indicate the legislative intention that healthy cows which are not fit to be slaughtered cannot be slaughtered at all. That is the thrust of section 4 of the Act. In other words there is total ban against slaughtering of healthy cows and other animals mentioned in the schedule under section 2 of the Act. This is the very essence of the Act
5. Now it becomes clear that when there is a total ban under the Act so far as slaughtering healthy cows which are not fit to be slaughtered as per section 4(1) is concerned, if that ban is to be lifted even for a day, it has to be shown that such lifting of ban is necessary for sub-serving any religious, medicinal or research purpose
6. It does not appear to be obligatory that a person must sacrifice a cow.
7. As slaughter of cows on Bakri Idd was not an essential religious practice for Muslims, total ban on cow’s slaughter on all days including Bakri Idd day would not be violative of Article 25(1).
8. In this connection, Das C.J., referred to the historical background regarding cow slaughtering from the times of Mughal emperors. Mughal Emperor Babar saw the wisdom of prohibiting the slaughter of cows as and by way of religious sacrifice and directed his son Humayun to follow this. Similarly, Emperors Akbar, Jahangir and Ahmad Shah, it is said, prohibited cow slaughter.
9. In view of this settled legal position it becomes obvious that if there is no fundamental right of a Muslim to insist on slaughter of healthy cow on Bakri Idd day, it cannot be a valid ground for exemption by the State under section 12 which would in turn enable slaughtering of such cows on Bakri Idd
10. Similarly it has to be held that if it is not necessary or essential to permit slaughter of a healthy cow for any religious purpose it would be equally not open to the State to invoke its exemption power under section 12 for such a religious purpose. We, therefore, entirely concur with the view of the High Court that slaughtering of healthy cows on Bakri Idd is not essential or required for religious purpose of Muslims.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional writ Jurisdiction - Original side
W.P.No. 1378 of 2010
Abhijit Das & Ors versus THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
W.P No.21591(W)OF 2010
Enamul Haqu & ors versus STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
For the petitioner in O.S. Matter : Mr Ballal Guhathakurta, Mr. Ganesh Banerjee,
Mr. Jai Surana and Mr A.K.Saraogi Advocates.
For the pertitioners in A.S.Matter : Mr. M.M.Querashi Sr. Advocate, Mr. Joydip Roy,
Ms. Rakhi shroff and Mr. S.G.Muscara advocates.
For State : Mr. Fazrul Haque, Advocate
Before the Hon’ble CHIEF JUSTICE, The Hon’ble JUSTICE ASHIM KUMAR ROY,
Date : 12 November 2010.
The court: These two petitions have been filed in public interest on the issue of sacrificing cow and its progeny as religious ritual on the occasion of Bakri-idd. The petition itself contains decision of this court which bans slaughter of cow on the occasion of Idd as religious ritual. Therefore no fruitful purpose will be served by again passing similar judgment and orders as the said judgment, which was upheld by the Supreme court ( State of West Bengal vs Asutosh Lahiri, reported in AIR 1995 S.C. 464) still holds good. The Authorities are, therefore bound to implement the provisions of West Bengal Animal Slaughter (Control) Act, 1950 and if any instance of cow slaughter on Bakri-id is brought to their notice, they will have to take cognizance and Act in accordance with law.
Therefore, we are disposing of these two petitions as filed withous there being any cause of action for the same and simple on an apprehension of the petitioners that cos and its progeny would be sacrificed as a religious ritual on the occasion of Bakri-idd.
It will be open for the petitioners to move this court in case they come across such incident and if the same is reported to the authorities and the authorities fail to take any action in the matter.
With this observation, the two petitions stand disposed of.
All parties concerned are to act on a signed Photostat copy and plain coy of this order on the usual undertakings
Sd/- J.N.PATEL CJ
ASHIM KUMAR ROY, J.
Essence of ORDER OF SUPREME COURT DT 16-11-94 (P464 of AIR 1995)
“The Act is meant for controlling the slaughter of animals including the cows and buffaloes. State will not have any jurisdiction or power to invoke section 12 for fulfilling such optional religious practice of Muslim community. Even if there is a certificate enabling a person to get concerned animal slaughtered he cannot slaughter it in any place other than the place prescribed in that behalf. Section 7 - whoever contravenes the provision of the Act shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months or with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees or with both. Section 8 makes the offences cognizable under the Act. Section 9 prescribes punishment for abetment of offences or even attempts to commit any such offence under the Act. In other words there is total ban against slaughtering of healthy cows and other animals. If that ban is to be lifted even for a day, it has to be shown that such lifting of ban is necessary for sub-serving any religious, medicinal or research purpose. As slaughter of cows on Bakri Idd was not an essential religious practice for Muslims, total ban on cow’s slaughter on all days including Bakri Idd day would not be violative of Article 25(1). Mughal Emperor Babar saw the wisdom of prohibiting the slaughter of cows as and by way of religious sacrifice and directed his son Humayun to follow this. Similarly, Emperors Akbar, Jahangir and Ahmad Shah, it is said, prohibited cow slaughter. As per Muslim books, only healthy animals can be sacrificed, but settled legal position, it becomes obvious that if there is no fundamental right of a Muslim to insist on slaughter of healthy cow on Bakri Idd day. It would be equally not open to the State to invoke its exemption power under section 12 for such a non essential religious purpose. “
Cow sale - purchase during Bakri Eid be banned, transportation as well and there are many temporary cow sheds at Bartalla Market beyond Metiabruz Police Station, area of Mitha Talao, Rahmat ka Khatal, "Ibrahim Road", behind Ekbalpur Police Station, "Mansa Tala Lane", around Khidderpur, Mominpur, Ekbalpur,
Watganj, Garden Reach, Metia Buruz and so on, there are thousands of cows are waiting their turn to sacrifice on 17-11-10, hence all these cows should be rescue and rehabilitated in Gaushala's.
PIL No. 381 of 2010 moved in the Supreme Court of India by OIPA in India representative Naresh Kadyan.
|Abhishek Kadyan||Delhi, India||11/05/2010|
|Oishimaya Sen||Kolkata, India||11/05/2010|
|shamalatha rao||Bangalore, IN||11/05/2010|
|Mervi Rantala||Tampere, Finland||11/05/2010|
|Naresh Kadyan Rep. OIPA in India||Delhi, India||11/05/2010|
|Sukanya Kadyan||Delhi, IN||11/05/2010|
|Laxmi Dass Ex. Chairman, KVIC||Delhi, IN||11/05/2010|
|Carin Zellerman||New york, NY||11/06/2010|
|Debasree Biswas||kolkata, India||11/06/2010|
|Paola Ghidotti||Milano, Italy||11/06/2010|
|Coryn Weber||Gingen, Germany||11/06/2010|
|Mia Huolman||Vaasa, Finland||11/06/2010|
|darius dirzinskas||london, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|Claudija Valenti||Melbourne, Australia||11/06/2010|
|Darlene Wood||Reidsville, NC||11/06/2010|
|Caroline Xavier||Mtlr, France||11/06/2010|
|Bob Ramczyk||Brown Deer, WI||11/06/2010|
|Jim T||........................, Australia||11/06/2010|
|Kim Smith||Auckland, New Zealand||11/06/2010|
|Diana Ferreira||Paços de Ferreira, Portugal||11/06/2010|
|Jo Lathwell||Trowbridge, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|charles mclachlan||none, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|Annika Pettersson||Boden, NY||11/06/2010|
|Constance Franklin||Los Angeles, CA||11/06/2010|
|Henrietta Smith||Auckland, New Zealand||11/06/2010|
|Angela Crystal Ara||Manchester, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|giane sales||recife, Brazil||11/06/2010|
|Jerry Mayeux||Hattiesburg, MS||11/06/2010|
|Dianne Harrop||Omaha, NE||11/06/2010|
|Olja Kaludjerovic||Kotor, WA||11/06/2010|
|elisabetta rossi||savona, Italy||11/06/2010|
|Mary Foley||cork, Ireland||11/06/2010|
|Annie Dillon||Scotland, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|Pamylle Greinke||Peconic, NY||11/06/2010|
|Andrea Da Costa||Melbourne, Australia||11/06/2010|
|Patrick Taylor||San Francisco, CA||11/06/2010|
|Leslie Fox||Bedford, NH||11/06/2010|
|Beth Stephens, Scott Stephens and Vicky Fuller, Our Family||Stratford, Canada||11/06/2010|
|Nadezhda Peneva||Alicante, Spain||11/06/2010|
|Ángel Marina||Palma de Mallorca, Spain||11/06/2010|
|Shirine Hossaini||Alexandria, VA||11/06/2010|
|Lilo Prinz||Au/ZH, AL||11/06/2010|
|Stephen Greene||Ellerbe, NC||11/06/2010|
|Judith Abel||Basel, Switzerland||11/06/2010|
|Anthony Ehredt||Chicago, IL||11/06/2010|
|dian wright||garland, TX||11/06/2010|
|Cristi Sturgill||Mount Vernon, KY||11/06/2010|
|Jason J Green||Spotsylvania, VA||11/06/2010|
|Kathleen Basiewicz||Dana, NC||11/06/2010|
|Elisabeth Bechmann||St. Pölten, Austria||11/06/2010|
|Peter Scott||Knox, IN||11/06/2010|
|Jenny O'Neil||Otero County, NM||11/06/2010|
|Helen Bertrand||New York, NY||11/06/2010|
|Jindra Cechova||Praha, Czech Republic||11/06/2010|
|heidi wollum||goteborg, Sweden||11/06/2010|
|Ann Cawley||Saint Joseph, MO||11/06/2010|
|Chris >^..^<||Jersey City, NJ||11/06/2010|
|Asli Gedik||frankfurt, Netherlands||11/06/2010|
|Ricardo Delgado Rodríguez||Benalmádena, Spain||11/06/2010|
|YOLANDA CASAS||Leganes, SC||11/06/2010|
|Patrizia Scally||Houston, TX||11/06/2010|
|cathala corine||Pierrelatte, France||11/06/2010|
|patricia myers||ancramdale, NY||11/06/2010|
|john649 lopez||reno, NV||11/06/2010|
|Tanwi Sandelwood||Onbekend, NE||11/06/2010|
|Ira Mak||Jerusalem, Israel||11/06/2010|
|Dawn Mason||Pottsville, PA||11/06/2010|
|Graciela Patrón Mederos||León, Spain||11/06/2010|
|Mandi T.||Saratoga, CA||11/06/2010|
|Samantha L||Chicago, IL||11/06/2010|
|Echo G.||Ashland, OH||11/06/2010|
|Cristina Seica||Anadia, Portugal||11/06/2010|
|Beas Basu||Kolkata, India||11/06/2010|
|Pilgrim G||Hertford, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|Dori Sanz||Madrid, Spain||11/06/2010|
|Timmi Sommer||Dana Point, CA||11/06/2010|
|Fenia Yfandi||Athens, Greece||11/06/2010|
|Jean Greene||Ellerbe, NC||11/06/2010|
|Viktoria Misinszki||Bacska Topolya, Serbia||11/06/2010|
|Natasha Leite de Moura||Rio de Janeiro, Brazil||11/06/2010|
|Amanda Flood||kenner, LA||11/06/2010|
|Pam Johnson||Lake Village, IN||11/06/2010|
|Jennifer Hall||Greeneville, TN||11/06/2010|
|CINDY COLLIER||WAKEFIELD, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|ivonne carlson||Bonita Springs, FL||11/06/2010|
|Nora Jones||Newcastle, Australia||11/06/2010|
|karen ericson||bothell, WA||11/06/2010|
|Ellen Gutfleisch||Sussex, WI||11/06/2010|
|Anneke Hut||Amersfoort, Netherlands||11/06/2010|
|Melissa Webber||Johannesburg, South Africa||11/06/2010|
|Magdalena Mazurek||Marco Island, FL||11/06/2010|
|Olivia Schlosser||Mansfield Center, CT||11/06/2010|
|Blue Ape With A Drum||Plymouth, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|Eleni Michaels||Sydney, Australia||11/06/2010|
|Rick Andersohn||Santa Rosa, CA||11/06/2010|
|SJ Champ||Los Angeles, CA||11/06/2010|
|Nicole Weber||Pasadena, MD||11/06/2010|
|Bev Brewis||Victoria, Canada||11/06/2010|
|Sharon Poore||Port St. Lucie, FL||11/06/2010|
|Christy Hill||Oshawa, Canada||11/06/2010|
|Candice McMillan||Edmonton, AL||11/06/2010|
|Mary Bell||Oakland, MD||11/06/2010|
|ryan mckenzie||apple valley, CA||11/06/2010|
|Marina Asher||Brooklyn, NY||11/06/2010|
|carol crunkhorn||New Zealand, FM||11/06/2010|
|Elisabeth Kelly||Washington, DC||11/06/2010|
|Mayra Lewis-Garcia||Compton, CA||11/06/2010|
|Mike Moore||Edinburgh, United Kingdom||11/06/2010|
|John Ruscigno||Brooklyn, NY||11/06/2010|
|Marta Barahona||Madrid, CA||11/06/2010|
|Brenda W||port colborne, CA||11/07/2010|
|Laura Broenink||Amersfoort, Netherlands||11/07/2010|
|Penni Norman||Des Moines, IA||11/07/2010|
|Yasiu Kruszynski||Chicago, IL||11/07/2010|
|Sami Signorino||Kokomo, IN||11/07/2010|
|George Martin||Loule, Portugal||11/07/2010|
|Morgan WEBER||Wattrelos, NY||11/07/2010|
|Jens U. Loehner||Hof, Germany||11/07/2010|
|Iwona Janeczko||Warsaw, Poland||11/07/2010|
|*C* .||Mosheim, TN||11/07/2010|
|Lori Andrews||annandale, NJ||11/07/2010|
|Sandra Seiça||Aveiro, Portugal||11/07/2010|
|Rochat Sylvie||La Sarraz, Switzerland||11/07/2010|
|Deb Brown||Raleigh, NC||11/07/2010|
|Maria F.||Verona, Italy||11/07/2010|
|Chantal Buslot||Hasselt, AL||11/07/2010|
|Laura Tatti||Oristano, Italy||11/07/2010|
|Michelle McCaulley||Corrales, NM||11/07/2010|
|Jezreel del Rosario||Pacifica, CA||11/07/2010|
|Chelsea Arne||Willimantic, CT||11/07/2010|
|Gilbert Zaragoza||Los Angeles, CA||11/07/2010|
|Tanya Willis||Lewes, DE||11/07/2010|
|Kay Ⓥ HelpSaveAnimals||Sax., Germany||11/07/2010|
|Levin Manabat||Portland, OR||11/07/2010|
|Vanditta Diwakar||Suva, HI||11/07/2010|
|annie cowling||DANBURY, CT||11/07/2010|
|Kelly Cleveland||Denver, CO||11/07/2010|
|Delliana of the Sea||Manitou Springs, CO||11/07/2010|
|annmarie devine||burtonport co donegal, Ireland||11/07/2010|
|JOAN YIELDING||ST LOUIS, MO||11/07/2010|
|carmen vasile||triuggio, Italy||11/07/2010|
|Cindy Poulin||Thetford Mines, CA||11/07/2010|
|Paulina Hoppel||Poznan, Poland||11/07/2010|
|Norma Jean Kabirpour Garza||San Antonio, TX||11/07/2010|
|enrico miolli||settimo torinese, Italy||11/07/2010|
|France Dombrowski||Quebec City, Canada||11/07/2010|
|Cindy Brower||Chicago, IL||11/07/2010|
|susann landes berger||dachau, Germany||11/07/2010|
|Joanne Beeson||Seattle, WA||11/07/2010|
|Kate kearney||Werrington Downs, Australia||11/07/2010|
|Susan Esposito||Staten Island, NY||11/07/2010|
|ARTURITU DE SIMONS||MEXICO, Mexico||11/07/2010|
|Ashley Maier||Morris, IL||11/07/2010|
|annette weakley||ruckersville, VA||11/07/2010|
|Jamie Halkyard||Auckland, New Zealand||11/07/2010|
|Emma Wellington||Townsville, IA||11/07/2010|
|Karen Tucker||Pensacola, FL||11/07/2010|
|Sheila Mahon||NY, NY||11/07/2010|
|Sheila Mahon||E Stroudsberg, PA||11/07/2010|
|Mary Ann Clark||Weatogue, CT||11/07/2010|
|Linda London-Burzynski||Roswell, GA||11/07/2010|
|Rebecca Sloan||Waihi, WA||11/07/2010|
|Hanna Erkel||Szentendre, Hungary||11/07/2010|
|Christianna Skoczek||Kittery Point, ME||11/07/2010|
|Gabriele Martinec||Dürnkrut, Austria||11/07/2010|
|I W||New york, NY||11/07/2010|
|Bryan D. Freehling||Lahaska, PA||11/07/2010|
|laurie sudol||clarkdale, AZ||11/07/2010|
|Judy Boone||Forest Hill, TX||11/07/2010|
|elena georgiadou||thessaloniki, Greece||11/07/2010|
|sebastien vigne||albi, France||11/07/2010|
|Herdis Daugbjerg||Beaverton, OR||11/07/2010|
|Julie van Niekerk||South Africa, SD||11/07/2010|
|Michele Mercer||Casa Grande, AZ||11/07/2010|
|sophie painvin||samoussy, France||11/08/2010|
|Elcin Tamolcen||Mugla, Turkey||11/08/2010|
|Isabella Duffy||Zernien, Germany||11/08/2010|
|carlee trent||springfield, OH||11/08/2010|
|Sanja Lalić Valečić||Zagreb, LA||11/08/2010|
|tina mann||sutton in ashfield, AL||11/08/2010|
|Lena Rehberger||Grebenhain, Germany||11/08/2010|
|marleen geudens||westerlo, Belgium||11/08/2010|
|Stephanie Schützinger||Hamburg, AL||11/08/2010|
|Filomena Viana||melksham, NY||11/08/2010|
|Claudia Koehler||Mitterndorf, Austria||11/08/2010|
|Radostina Dubarova||Burgas, Bulgaria||11/08/2010|
|ana maria molina||zarzalejo, Spain||11/08/2010|
|ally Vena||ny, NY||11/08/2010|
|MARIA CHORATTA||NICOSIA, Cyprus||11/08/2010|
|Demeter Fernandez||Melbourne, Australia||11/08/2010|
|Tippers a||Ft Pierce, FL||11/08/2010|
|Michela Messineo||Roma, Italy||11/08/2010|
|Deborah Pattinson||Munich, GU||11/08/2010|
|Peggy Acosta||Womelsdorf, PA||11/08/2010|
|Andrea Oefinger||Newtown, CT||11/08/2010|
|Maria P||Dunstable, MA||11/08/2010|
|Riccardo Ricceri||Arezzo, Italy||11/08/2010|
|Roberta Delfini||Ponzone, Italy||11/08/2010|
|james m nordlund||Fargo, ND||11/08/2010|
|lisa salazar||Foster City, CA||11/08/2010|
|Hege Marit Hostad||Elnesvågen, Norway||11/08/2010|
|Kathy Koloze||Dallas, TX||11/08/2010|
|katira tejeda||plano, TX||11/08/2010|
|Carla Vieira||Somerville, MA||11/08/2010|
|laura raforth||rochester, NY||11/08/2010|
|Fulvia Marino||Torre Annunziata, Italy||11/08/2010|
|Erica Borremans||Brussels BELGIUM, MI||11/08/2010|
|Theresa Vaccaro||Plainfield, NJ||11/08/2010|
|Sandra Hudson-Knapp||Poultney, VT||11/08/2010|
|Beata Toth||London, United Kingdom||11/08/2010|
|Diane Pease||Littleton, NH||11/08/2010|
|sherri isaac||ypailanti, MI||11/08/2010|
|Henri De Decker||Tisselt, Belgium||11/08/2010|
|Denise L.||Fords, NJ||11/08/2010|
|Mackenna Carr||Fayetteville, NC||11/08/2010|
|Melissa Wise||Fort Worth, TX||11/08/2010|
|Pauline Cousins||chepstow gwent, United Kingdom||11/08/2010|
|tom hume||sydney New Sout Wales Australia, AL||11/08/2010|
|Caleb Laieski||Phoenix, AZ||11/08/2010|
|Faith Campbell||Ontario, Canada||11/08/2010|
|Mary Alexander||Glen Allen, VA||11/08/2010|
|Bobbie Murray||Raleigh, NC||11/08/2010|
|Andrea Audia||Fairmont, WV||11/08/2010|
|Lisa Zarafonetis||Dallas, TX||11/08/2010|
|Janet Nelson||Mack, CO||11/08/2010|
|Robert Rodriguez||los angeles, CA||11/08/2010|
|Natasa Delic||Belgrade, Serbia||11/09/2010|
|yael kv||Nijmegen, Netherlands||11/09/2010|
|nicolette ludolphi||bremen, DE||11/09/2010|
|Vivienne Ben-Shir||London, United Kingdom||11/09/2010|
|josephine skitt||willenhall, AL||11/09/2010|
|polly pagan||london, United Kingdom||11/09/2010|
|Martine Derouaux||Bruxelles, Belgium||11/09/2010|
|Camelia Rizolu||Munich, Germany||11/09/2010|
|Michael Dontas||Lancaster, PA||11/09/2010|
|Traci Newcomb||Rocky Mount, NC||11/09/2010|
|Rachel Mangan||North Olmsted, OH||11/09/2010|
|Rebecca Butler||Westerly, RI||11/09/2010|
|sue Schümmer||Ulm, DE||11/09/2010|
|gerlinde palsingh||vienna, WY||11/09/2010|
|Angie Starling||Hickory, NC||11/09/2010|
|J R||Buzet, Croatia||11/09/2010|
|Paulo Magalhaes||New York, NY||11/09/2010|
|Julie Goldman||Chesterfield, MO||11/09/2010|
|Barbara McNamara||Joppa, MD||11/09/2010|
|Stephanie Malara||Carlsbad, NM||11/09/2010|
|Cynthia Henley||Houston, TX||11/09/2010|
|Angelika Stratiichuk||Ourem, Portugal||11/09/2010|
|Kaji Siva||Toronto, Canada||11/09/2010|
|Suni Ibarra||Rohnert Park,, CA||11/09/2010|
|Darlene Davis||Detroit, MI||11/09/2010|
|Sophia Paraschou||alexandroupolis, Greece||11/09/2010|
|Lori Kegler||San Pedro, CA||11/09/2010|
|Arthur Liles||China Grove, NC||11/10/2010|
|Irena Gabut||Krakow, Poland||11/10/2010|
|Lorri Makela||Angel Fire, NM||11/10/2010|
|Mike Schena||parkcity, IL||11/10/2010|
|Kristy Mitchell||Stephenville, TX||11/10/2010|
|Thorsten Kassebeer||Eime, Germany||11/10/2010|
|Tracey Horne||palmerston north, New Zealand||11/10/2010|
|DR THEODORA MANOLAS||JACKSON HEIGHTS, NY||11/10/2010|
|sarah vanbelle||bruxelles, Belgium||11/11/2010|
|Anita Clemmer||Jessup, MD||11/11/2010|
|annmarie stocker||haughton, LA||11/11/2010|
|Leila Jackson||Beverly Hills, CA||11/12/2010|
|michael stemple||pickerington, OH||11/12/2010|
|Per Ingebrigtsen||Bergen norge, Norway||11/12/2010|
|Jennifer Bates||Chevy Chase, MD||11/12/2010|
|Henriette Matthijssen||Boyle, Alberta,, Canada||11/13/2010|
|Sudershan Dhandharia||Kolkatta, India||11/13/2010|
|chris beal||louth, TX||11/13/2010|
|Satvir S Chaudhry||Panchkula, India||11/14/2010|
|Wendy Forster||Manchester, United Kingdom||11/14/2010|
|Matsi Yasei||McKinney, TX||11/14/2010|
|marilyn miller||la mesa, CA||11/15/2010|
|Social Service||Delhi, IN||11/15/2010|
|abhijit das||kolkata, India||11/16/2010|
|Tulula Fanjoy||Casa Grande, AZ||11/16/2010|
|Susannah Kegler||San pedro, CA||11/17/2010|
|Pamela Bonaventura||Taormina, Italy||11/19/2010|
|Sanja Tamarut||Rijeka, Croatia||11/20/2010|
|Colleen Klaum||Allentown, PA||11/20/2010|
|De Andre Nickens||Los Angeles, CA||11/20/2010|
|Joan E Loza Mobry||Madison, WI||11/20/2010|
|Marely Rios||Spring, TX||11/20/2010|
|Pia Mustonen||Tampere, Finland||11/21/2010|